FIFTH ANNUAL CONFERNCE 2024
Our Fifth Annual APAG Conference was held on March 9 and 10, 2024. It was a wonderful event full of engaging panels and speakers and our First Annual APAG Awards. We began our weekend with our keynote speaker, Lynn Goldsmith who gave a very inspiring talk about her career and shared many of her amazing photographs.
It was followed by two panels one on Artificial Intelligence and Social Media and followed up with a panel on museums and institutions. That evening we held our First Annual Awards party at Barnjoo, and gave out seven awards for Lifetime Achievement in photography, (Chester Higgins and Neal Slavin) archive management (Estate of Tseng Kwong Chi and the Arthur Rothstein Legacy Project) member of the year (Leslie Smolan/Rodney Smith Archive), distinguished service (Alice Sachs Zimet) and the Beacon award (Lynn Goldsmith).
We want to thank our host Charles Traub and The School of Visual Arts for sharing “The Big Room” with us for the weekend, as well as our major sponsors Robert Gurbo and the Andre and Elizabeth Kertesz Foundation, Muus Collection and the Leonian Foundation.
Thank you to all the panelists and attendees who traveled to NYC from California, Arizona, Texas, Missouri, Massachusetts, Maine, Vermont and New Jersey to attend. Look forward to next year!
Join us for APAG’s 5th annual weekend conference
The Art and Commerce of Photography Archives
on March 9th and 10th, 2024
at the School of Visual Arts, NYC
www.apag.us/about
$450 – 2 day – (includes cocktail party) / $295 – 1 day
We are especially honored to welcome our keynote speaker, Lynn Goldsmith, an acclaimed photographer whose work has significantly influenced the landscape of contemporary photography. Lynn’s insights and experiences are sure to inspire and enlighten our discussions.
Conference Highlights:
Engaging sessions covering a range of topics such as galleries and auctions to the latest trends in photography commerce. Opportunities for networking with fellow photography professionals. Also, included breakout sessions, and a Saturday night cocktail party with the first annual APAG Awards!
Saturday March 9, 2024
8:30am Registration can coffee/pastries
9:30am – 10:30am KEYNOTE SPEAKER – LYNN GOLDSMITH
10:45 – 12:15pm
PANEL 1 From Disruption to Transformation AI and Social Media Trends in Photography
Cara Erdman (Licensing Executive, Artists Rights Society)
Andrew Smith (Andrew Smith Gallery)
Moderator: Stephen McCamman
Lunch – 12:30 – 1:30 (on your own)
1:45pm – 3:30pm
Panel 2 – Curating the Future: Innovative Approaches in Museum Exhibitions and Collections
Don Carleton (Executive Director, Dolph Briscoe Center)
Sean Corcoran (Curator of Prints and Photographs, Museum of the City of New York)
Moderator: Mary Engel
Breakout Sessions 3:45
Awards Party – 5:30 – 7:30pm (Awards at 6:30pm)
Sunday March 10, 2024
9:15 – 9:45 am check in/coffee
9:45 am Awards review / “In Memoriam”
10:00 – 11:30am
Panel 3 – State of the Art Market: Navigating Galleries and Auctions Today
Stephen Perloff (The Photo Review)
Alice Sachs Zimet (Arts + Business Partners)
1145am – 1:15pm
Panel 4 – Navigating the Legal Landscape: Contracts and Copyright Essentials
Nate Kleinman (attorney, McCulloch Kleinman Law)
Patrick K. Lin (Center for Art Law)
Lunch 1:15 – 2: 15 (on your own)
2:30 – 4:00
Panel 5 – Best Practices in Archive Management
Margit Erb (Saul Leiter Foundation)
Robert Gurbo (Andre Kertesz Estate)
Amanda Smith (MUUS Collection)
Moderator: Stephen Perloff
4:15 – 5:15pm
Breakout sessions
5:30 Conference ends…
PANELIST BIOS
DON CARLETON
Dr. Don Carleton is the founding executive director of the Dolph Briscoe Center for American History (1991) and he holds the J. R. Parten Chair in the Archives of American History at the University of Texas at Austin (UT-Austin). He is the author of fourteen books, including Red Scare; Conversations with Cronkite; Struggle for Justice: Four Decades of Civil Rights Photography; and The Governor and the Colonel: A Dual Biography of William P. Hobby and Oveta Culp Hobby.
He also edited and contributed the preface to Flash of Light, Wall of Fire: Japanese Photographs Documenting the Atomic Bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki (University of Texas Press, 2020), which Vogue Italia recognized as one of the notable books of photography published in 2020. Dr. Carleton has worked as a historian, lecturer, and researcher in Nicaragua, Australia, Japan, the United Kingdom, France, Israel, the Czech Republic, Poland, and Romania. As a history faculty member at UT-Austin, he has taught a graduate seminar on methods and sources, which featured the use of photographs for historical research. In October 2020, Carleton launched the Briscoe Center’s podcast, “American Rhapsody,” which he hosts. In 2015, the Texas Democracy Foundation honored him with its Bernard Rapoport Award for support of the First Amendment.
SEAN CORCORAN
Sean Corcoran is the Senior Curator of Prints and Photographs at the Museum of the City of New York. He previously served as Assistant Curator of Photography at George Eastman Museum, Rochester, NY. His exhibitions have included Through a Different Lens: Stanley Kubrick Photographs, Brooklyn: The City Within: Photographs by Alex Webb and Rebecca Norris Webb and the Museum’s inaugural contemporary photography Triennial, New York Now: Home. He has written extensively on photography, contributing to more than two dozen publications, including essays for Elliott Erwitt: At Home and Around the World (Aperture), and I See a City: Todd Webb’s New York
(Thames & Hudson), Loisaida: Street Work 1984-1990 by Tria Giovan (Damiani) and others.
MARGIT ERB
Margit Erb is the founder and director of the Saul Leiter Foundation. She represented Leiter at Howard Greenberg Gallery from 1996 until the artist’s death in 2013, also assisting him in organizing his archive. She has worked on all of Leiter’s books, including his first monograph, Early Color (Steidl, 2006), and she coproduced the 2013 documentary In No Great Hurry: 13 Lessons in Life with Saul Leiter. In the years since Leiter’s passing, the foundation has coproduced museum exhibitions and book releases worldwide, including the 2023 exhibitions Saul Leiter: Assemblages at Les Rencontres d’Arles and Saul Leiter: Origins in Color at the Bunkamura Museum of Art, Tokyo. Today, Margit, along with her husband, Michael Parillo, maintains Leiter’s extensive archive of photographs and paintings, located in the artist’s former studio in New York City’s East Village. The foundation recently published two books with Thames & Hudson, The Unseen Saul Leiter and Saul Leiter: The Centennial Retrospective.
CARA ERDMAN
Cara Erdman is a Licensing Executive & Manager of Membership Services at Artists Rights Society, where she works with artists to demystify the world of copyright and handles licensing deals in a number of industries including consumer products, fashion & apparel, museums & education and more. Previously, she worked in development at CUE Art Foundation, supporting grants for exhibitions for emerging and under-recognized artists in New York City.
ROBERT GURBO
Robert Gurbo, long time curator of the Estate of Andre Kertész and the André & Elizabeth Kertész Foundation worked with Kertész over the last 7 years his life and has spent the last 40 years combing through the archive. He is co-author of the catalog that accompanied the 2005 National Gallery exhibit, André Kertész, published by Princeton University Press. He is editor and author of Andre Kertész: The Early Years, and Andre Kertész: The Polaroids. He also organized the reissue of Kertész’s seminal book, On Reading. He is currently working on a book of Kertész’s self-portraits. Gurbo has been an advisor consultant to auction houses, museums and institutions such as The French Ministry of Culture, Jeu De Paume, Museum of Fine Arts in Budapest, The Art Institute of Chicago, MoMA, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, The Getty, International Center of Photography, The National Gallery of Art, Virginia Museum of Fine Arts and many more.
Gurbo defines his role as curator as something he was born to do. “While I always liked photography as a child, I became obsessed with Andre Kertész’s work at age 16 when I received a small book of his photographs as a gift. That I actually met and worked with him was beyond my wildest dreams. My fascination, understanding and love for the man and his photographs has only grown over the 40 years I have been privileged to be steward of this incredible archive.” He has recently been appointed trustee and managing director.
NATE KLEINMAN
Nate Kleinman is a partner at the McCulloch Kleinman law firm, a boutique copyright litigation and intellectual property firm with offices in New York City and Seattle. Nate’s practice focuses almost exclusively on the photography industry, representing photographers across the country seeking to enforce their copyrights, as well as providing advice and guidance in the negotiation of licensing and royalty agreements. Nate received his undergraduate degree in design management from Parsons School of Design in 2010, where he first became interested in the intersection of art and law, and went on to receive his J.D. from Temple University’s Beasley School of Law in 2013. Nate is an active member of the U.S. Copyright Society, and also serves on the Intellectual Property Committee of the Federal Bar Council. In his free time, Nate continues to make art himself, giving him a unique perspective and appreciation for his clients’ work which further motivates his legal practice.
PATRICK K. LIN
Patrick K. Lin is an attorney and researcher focused on AI, privacy, and copyright. He is the author of Machine See, Machine Do, a book about technology, history, and policy. Currently, Patrick is the Judith Bresler Fellow at the Center for Art Law, where he oversees the Center’s clinical program, focusing on topics in copyright, legacy and estate planning, and artist-dealer relations.
STEPHEN PERLOFF
Stephen Perloff is the founder and editor of The Photo Review, a critical journal of international scope publishing since 1976, and editor of The Photograph Collector, the leading source of information on the photography art market. He is also the editor of The Daguerreian Society Quarterly and The Daguerreian Annual. He has curated more than a score of exhibitions and is a recipient of the Colin Ford Award for Curatorship from the Royal Photographic Society. He also has a long career as an exhibiting photographer and his photographs reside in many museum and private collections.
AMANDA SMITH
Amanda Smith is the director of archives at MUUS Collection. She specializes in organizing, managing, interpreting and providing access to photographers’ archives, especially those of underknown yet prolific creators. Most recently she led the processing of the Deborah Turbeville archive, assisted in the curation of the traveling exhibition Deborah Turbeville: Photocollage and acted as editorial manager for its companion monograph (Thames & Hudson 2023). Formerly the assistant director and head archivist at The Gordon Parks Foundation, Smith led the foundation through a pivotal period in its growth and supported the production of many exhibitions as well as a dozen books. She holds a master’s degree in photographic preservation and collections management from Ryerson University and a bachelor’s degree in art history and American studies from Rutgers University.
ANDREW SMITH
Andrew Smith started his photography business in 1974, in Santa Fe, working with prints by Edward Curtis. In 1975, as a member and eventual director of the Center of the Eye Photography Collaborative, he began to work with a variety of contemporary artists. He graduated from the University of New Mexico law school in 1982 and practices law for 3 years while engaged in his photography business. He opened a public gallery, Andrew Smith Gallery, Inc. in Albuquerque, New Mexico in 1984, moving the gallery to Santa Fe in 1986. Moved to Tucson in 2018 and will be scaling back the public space to an office in the fall of 2024.
Over the last 50 years the Andrew Smith Gallery in Albuquerque, Santa Fe and Tucson has presented over 150 exhibitions and hosted over 1,000,000 visitors. It has bought, sold and brokered the sale of approximately 200,000 photographs, worth more than $150,000,000.00. He has worked with and represented many many hundreds of photographers during this time
The gallery is best known by collectors and museums as the international source for significant 19th and 20th century photographs of the American West, Ansel adams, Contemporary Indigenous Photographers as well as for working with large collections and archives. He has been working on artists legacy projects for over 20 years.
ALICE SACHS ZIMET
Alice Sachs Zimet is President, Arts + Business Partners, a consulting boutique which she founded in 1999 specializing in the fine art photography marketplace.
As a collector, advisor, and educator, Zimet began to collect fine art photography in 1985 and has amassed a museum-quality collection of over 350+ images by 141 different photographers from 20th Century masters to the present.
Zimet is Chair, Photography Curatorial Committee, Harvard Art Museums, Cambridge; Chair, Collections Committee, International Center of Photography (ICP), New York; Board Member, Magnum Foundation, New York; Advisory Board Member: Center of Photography at Woodstock (CPW), Kingston, and American Photography Archives Group (APAG), NewYork. She teaches regularly for Christie’s Education, the ICP School, Maine Media College +Workshops, and the Colorado Photographic Art Center (CPAC) where she teaches workshops on how to collect photography and how photographers can better access the marketplace.Zimet pioneered the field of corporate sponsorship as Director, Worldwide Cultural Affairs,The Chase Manhattan Bank (20 years) where she used the arts as a strategic marketing tool across 14 countries and 20 US cities, generating $2 Billion in new business for the bank. She is Adjunct Professor, New York University’s Graduate Program, Arts Administration.
2018 Conference at ICP
Our Fourth Annual 2018 APAG Seminar was held on December 8 and 9, 2018. It was another successful event for the attendees, panelists and our new sponsors. We were very pleased to have the support once again of our incredible host, the International Center of Photography, ICP. Our new sponsors were the Phillip and Edith Leonian Foundation, Uovo and Picturae. Most of the panelists traveled to NYC from seven states, and we had a full house. We have almost outgrown ICP and just in time, as hopefully at the new location downtown, there will be an even larger space for us to have our seminar next year!
“KUDOS on a wonderful conference, well run, fascinating speakers and cutting edge with Bitcoin panel. I learned much and connected with friends new and old. Thank you again for doing so much for families of photographers like me. I’m so grateful to have connected with you and APAG – it’s going to be a real slog but now I feel that I’m in a community, not alone doing it.” Jessica Seigel
“Mary, I just wanted to thank you for an a wonderful seminar – what a wealth of information and expertise! APAG has truly become an invaluable resource for me and a treasured group of colleagues and friends. THANK YOU for all you do!!” Margaret McCarthy
All photos below – Copyright Grayson Dantzic Photography
All photos below – Copyright Harris Fogel
Fourth Annual APAG Seminar 12/8/18 and 12/9/18 at the School at ICP at 1114 Sixth Avenue, NYC.
PANELISTS:
Ellen Boughn – ellenboughn.com
Alla Efimova, PhD – thekunstworks.com
Loni Efron – ilon.com / intagliogroup.com
Monique Fischer – nedcc.org
Julie Grahame – juliegrahame.com / karsh.org
Dennis Inch – Archival Methods.com
Maria Kessler – bloctechmedia.com
Dr. Loren E. Miller – nmaahc.org
Hanoch Sheps – mazzolalindstrom
Andrew Smith – andrewsmithgallery.com
Jennifer Stoots – Stootsllc.com
Mary Virginia Swanson – maryvirginiaswanson.com
Katie Wagner, Esq. – Katie Wagner, Esq
MODERATORS:
A.D. Coleman – A.D.Coleman
Mary Engel APAG / orkinphoto.com
Julie Grahame – juliegrahame
Stella Kramer – stellakramer
Stephen Perloff – photoreview.org
Andrew Smith – Andrewsmithgallery
Saturday, December 8, 2018
Panel #1: 10:00 – 11:30am
Museum Curators: How Do They Find Work For Their Exhibitions and Collections.
Panelists: Dr. Loren Miller, Alla Efimova, PhD – Moderator: Mary Engel
Panel #2: 11:45 – 1:15pm
Conservation and Preservation: What You need to Know to Protect Your Archives
Panelists: Monique Fischer, Dennis Inch – Moderator: Stephen Perloff
Lunch: 1:15 – 2:15pm (on your own)
Panel #3 : 2:30 – 4:00pm
Licensing and Marketing: Learn All About It From the Experts
Panelists: Mary Virginia Swanson, Julie Grahame – Moderator: Stella Kramer
Coffee break: 4:00 – 4:30
Breakout Sessions: 4:30 – 5:30pm
Sunday, December 9, 2018
Panel #4: 10:00 – 11:30am
From a Legal Perspective: Contracts and Copyright
Panelists: Hanoch Sheps, Kathryn E. Wagner Esq. – Moderator: A.D. Coleman
Panel #5: 11:45 – 1:15pm
What’s it Worth? Appraising Prints and Copyrights Associated with an Archive”
Panelists: Jennifer Stoots, Ellen Boughn – Moderator: Andrew Smith
Lunch: 1:15 – 2:15pm
Panel #6: 2:30 – 4:00pm
The Internet: New Technology and How It Will Impact Our Industry
Panelists: Loni Efron, Maria Kessler – Moderator: Julie Grahame
Coffee break: 4:00 – 4:30pm
Breakout Sessions: 4:30 – 5:30pm
SPONSORS:
Phillip and Edith Leonian Foundation
UOVO
Picturae
SEMINAR FEES:
(Includes 3 panels each day, breakfast, afternoon coffee, breakout sessions and Sat. evening party)
One Day- APAG member $225 / non-member $250
Two Days – APAG member $ 400 / non-member $450
Additional attendee from an archive/photo studio – member $175 each day
HOTELS: Below are hotels in Midtown that are within walking distance of ICP. There are many other Manhattan hotels that are also convenient by subway, bus, or cab. ICP is located at 1114 Sixth Avenue, at 43rd Street.
Large Chain Hotels:
Millenium Broadway, Times Square
Marriott Marquis
Small Boutique Hotels:
Paramount
Night Hotel, Theater District or Times Square
APAG 2017 Seminar on March 11 & 12 a success!
Thank you to everyone who attended the 3rd Annual 2017 APAG Seminar this past weekend! We had 45 attendees and 15 panelists. The response was amazing, and I appreciate all the kind remarks about how inspiring and educational it was! I really appreciate the assistance from our fantastic tech Francesco and Alejandro from ICP, and Efrem, Lily, Pamela and especially Annie, one of our charter members. A huge thank you to my board who is always there when I need them to lend their expertise and unwavering support, Grayson Dantzic, Julie Grahame and Ernest Londa.
I was very pleased to release an advance copy of THE PHOTO ARCHIVE HANDBOOK. Thanks to the contributors to the book, Andrew Smith, Kenneth Falcon, Robin Moore, Julie Grahame and Jennifer Stoots and to the photographers who loaned photos. Also, to my editor Judy Herrmann, and especially my longtime collaborator and wonderful graphic designer, Christine Zamora of CZ Design, whose professionalism, friendly and patient manner always helps us get the job done on deadline! Additional copies will be at our table at AIPAD, and they will also be available online at that time.
I am always appreciative to our generous hosts ICP, who help us every step of the way. Including Mark Lubell who has supported APAG and its mission for many years, and Deirdre Donohue and Maya Benton who were fantastic panelists, and Erica Somerwitz who handled all the logistics, and was a pleasure to work with.
– Mary Engel, Founder and President
Just wanted to let you know how much we appreciated the seminar this weekend on legacy management. The panelists, the flow of information, were truly precious. Everybody gained a better understanding of the end of life issues facing us image makers. Chester Higgins Jr.
Huge appreciation for the most wonderful and beneficial program you made happen. Truly brilliant!! Susan May Tell
All photos copyright Grayson Dantzic
Saturday, March 11, 2017
Panel: 10:00 – 11:30am
What is the current state of copyright given the political climate, and how do we protect our photographs?
Panelists: Eugene Mopsik, John Pelosi
Panel: 11:45 – 1:15pm
Inside the collector’s mind: branding, marketing and getting your collection…placed.
Panelists: W.M. Hunt, Alice Zimet
Lunch: 1:15 – 2:15pm (on your own)
Panel: 2:30 – 4:00pm
Organizing and working with archives: how to make them accessible for critics, curators, historians and researchers
Panelists: Maya Benton, A.D. Coleman and Douglas Sheer
Breakout Sessions: 4:15 – 5:15pm
Sunday, March 12, 2017
Panel: 10:00 – 11:30am
What are institutions looking for and how do they build their collections?
Panelists: Deidre Donohue, Lisa McCarty, Leslie Squyres
Panel: 11:45 – 1:15pm
Legacy of an archive: how to protect and manage it.
Panelists: Robert Gurbo, Robin Moore, Andrew Smith
Lunch: 1:15 – 2:15pm
Panel: 2:30 – 4:00pm
Auctions, Galleries and the Press 101: What you need to know.
Panelists: Emily Bierman, Daniel Cooney, Stephen Perloff
Breakout Sessions: 4:15 – 5:15pm
SEMINAR FEES:
(Fees include all panels, lite breakfast and afternoon coffee, and Saturday night party!)
See below for info on payment by credit card via PAYPAL, or by check
- One Day – APAG member $175 / Non-member $200
- Two Days – APAG member $325 / Non-member $350
- Two people both days, member $575
- Two people both days, non-member, $600
2nd Annual APAG 2015 Seminar a success!
Sunday, September 20, 2015
The seminar concluded last night as I went to a classroom, and found a breakout session still going strong, and I had to inform them that it was 6:30 and everyone else had left already! I think they might have stayed all night listening to George Miles from Yale, Lisa McCarty from Duke and Jennifer Watts from The Huntington, the esteemed panel who graciously stayed late answering all their questions.
I appreciate all the kind words I have received, and I am so pleased that the 2nd Annual APAG seminar was a great success! Thanks to all the attendees and panelists who travelled from 13 states and Canada! I am so appreciative to my wonderful volunteers, Bryan, Ryan, Danny, Ronnie and Stephanie! I could not do this without the passion and support of my board Grayson Dantzic, Ernest Londa and our newest member Julie Grahame! Our wonderful accountant David Aron deserves our appreciation for his help all year. Andrew Smith from the Andrew Smith Gallery of Santa Fe, New Mexico was a big help in all the pre-planning of the event, and moderated several panels.
Of course, our host ICP helped make the entire event run smoothly, including Erica, Christina, Nicole and Kemal who videotaped the entire event, and I am eternally grateful for Phil Block and Mark Lubell’s continued support, who were both able to welcome everyone on Friday morning! Thank you also to all the APAG members who support APAG throughout the year!
Mary Engel, Founder and President, APAG
“The APAG seminar is a must for anyone wanting to know more about preserving and presenting an archive. The two day event took place in a most cordial atomosphere where all were welcome and information flowed freely. Great people to be with and learn from.” -Laurence Salzmann, photographer
“Thank you so much for those two wonderful days. My head is full of information, it will take me a while to digest it all.” -Ariel Borremans, Director Guy Borremans Archive
PRESS/BLOGS
“Holding On and Letting Go” by A.D. Coleman, Photocritic International
“In Appreciation” by Judith Thompson, Harold Feinstein’s wife
RADIO INTERVIEW
In this interview with Mary Engel and Executive Vice President Grayson Dantzic we discuss the creation of APAG, and the 2nd Annual APAG Conference in New York, held at the International Center of Photography, ICP, in September 2015. The conference featured leading curators, archivists, librarians, foundations, and photographers on the topics of preservation, strategy, and contemporary concerns and approaches.
With so many families of photographers and professionals trying to understand how best to pass on their legacy, and what to do with an inherited archive, and a myriad of approaches and options, the task can be daunting. If you are interested in photography, estate planning, leaving a legacy, and preserving a photographic archive, then listen in! Recorded at ICP in New York City, in September 2015 by Harris Fogel. Mac Edition Radio
VIDEO
See all of our videos on the APAG Youtube Channel.
PHOTOS
All color photos above – Copyright Harris Fogel / All black and white photos above – Copyright Grayson Dantzic